psychologist comparison

What’s the Difference Between a Psychologist and a Psychotherapist

What’s the Difference Between a Psychologist and a Psychotherapist, and Who Should You See?

When it comes to taking care of your mental health, choosing the right professional can be both empowering and confusing. Many people begin their mental health journey by asking: “What’s the difference between a psychologist and a psychotherapist?” While both roles are essential in the landscape of mental wellness and offer talk-based therapy, they differ in training, scope, qualifications, and areas of specialization. Understanding these differences helps ensure that you receive the type of support best suited to your individual needs.

At Wellman Psychology, our Chicago Psychologist aims to demystify the process of seeking mental health care by matching individuals with professionals who are not only highly trained but also the right fit emotionally and clinically. This guide will help you navigate the distinction between psychologists and psychotherapists so you can take the next step confidently and effectively.

What’s the Difference Between a Psychologist and a Psychotherapist

Understanding the Roles of Mental Health Professionals

In today’s world, mental health is more openly discussed than ever, but the roles and titles of mental health professionals can still cause confusion. Whether you're experiencing symptoms of anxiety, dealing with trauma, facing life transitions, or simply looking for a space to process emotions, knowing who to turn to is key.

There are various mental health professionals, including psychotherapists, psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, and counselors, who play unique and overlapping roles in emotional and psychological care. The first step in getting the right help is understanding what each professional does, how they are trained, and what kind of support they can provide.

What’s the Difference Between a Psychologist and a Psychotherapist?

The fundamental difference between a psychologist and a psychotherapist lies in their educational background, clinical training, and legal authority, especially regarding mental health diagnoses.

  • Psychologists undergo rigorous academic training and are qualified to assess, diagnose, and treat a wide range of mental health conditions. In many jurisdictions (such as Ontario), psychologists, alongside physicians and nurse practitioners, are authorized to formally communicate mental health diagnoses.

  • Psychotherapists, by contrast, specialize in providing talk-based therapy aimed at supporting individuals through emotional and behavioral challenges. While they are highly skilled in therapeutic techniques, they typically do not offer formal psychological diagnoses unless they have dual credentials.

Despite these differences, both professionals can provide effective therapy, and your choice may depend on the complexity of your condition, your treatment goals, and the therapeutic approach you prefer.

What is a Psychotherapist Also Known As?

A psychotherapist is commonly referred to as a therapist, or in some contexts, a talking therapist. These titles are often used interchangeably in day-to-day conversations. Psychotherapists work with clients to explore their emotions, behaviors, relationships, and life challenges through structured dialogue.

They create a safe, empathetic space where clients feel seen, heard, and supported. The primary goal of a psychotherapist is to guide individuals toward mental clarity, emotional regulation, and personal growth through evidence-based therapeutic methods.

Psychotherapist: Education, Training, and Role

Education and Training

Psychotherapists typically hold a Bachelor’s or Master’s degree in fields such as:

  • Psychology

  • Counselling

  • Psychotherapy

  • Social Work

  • Mental Health Studies

Their training includes clinical supervision, therapeutic workshops, and hands-on practice with various client populations. Psychotherapists must meet professional standards set by regional regulatory bodies, ensuring they’re equipped to support clients ethically and effectively.

Therapy Modalities

Psychotherapists are trained in multiple therapeutic approaches, including:

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)

  • Psychodynamic Therapy

  • Humanistic and Person-Centered Therapy

  • Art and Play Therapy

  • Systemic and Family Therapy

Core Role

The primary role of a psychotherapist is to help individuals:

  • Process emotions and life events

  • Cope with stress, depression, and anxiety

  • Overcome traumatic experiences

  • Improve self-esteem and relationships

Sessions may range from short-term problem-solving to long-term in-depth therapy depending on the individual’s needs.

Psychologist: Education, Training, and Role

Education and Credentials

Psychologists are among the most highly trained mental health professionals. Their academic path typically includes:

  • A Master’s degree followed by a Doctoral degree (PhD or PsyD) in psychology

  • At least 5–6 years of advanced education

  • Over 2500 clinical hours, including practicum, residency, and supervised practice

Specializations

Psychologists often choose a specific field of practice, such as:

  • Clinical Psychology

  • Counseling Psychology

  • Educational or School Psychology

  • Forensic Psychology

  • Sports Psychology

Core Role

Psychologists:

  • Conduct psychological assessments and diagnostic testing

  • Help clients understand the root causes of their thoughts and behaviors

  • Provide evidence-based therapy

  • Work with complex mental health disorders such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or personality disorders

They do not prescribe medications, but often collaborate with psychiatrists when pharmacological intervention is needed.

Therapist vs Psychologist: Key Differences

Category

Psychotherapist (Therapist)

Psychologist

Also Known As

Therapist, Talking Therapist

N/A

Education

Bachelor’s/Master’s

5–6 Years Master’s + Doctorate

Scope of Practice

Talk therapy, emotional support

Diagnosis, therapy, and psychological assessments

Can Diagnose?

Depends on jurisdiction

Yes (with license)

Can Prescribe?

No

No

Specializations

CBT, family therapy, trauma

Clinical, forensic, counseling, and educational psychology

Referral Capability

May refer to a psychologist or a psychiatrist

May refer to a psychiatrist if medication is needed

While psychotherapists focus on emotional processing and behavioral change, psychologists bring an analytical lens to mental health, making both roles valuable in different contexts.

Therapy Methods and Treatment Goals

Both psychotherapists and psychologists use talk-based therapy, but their goals and techniques may differ:

  • Psychotherapists guide clients through emotional challenges using relationship-based and often experiential approaches.

  • Psychologists apply theory-driven methods to explore and alter deeper cognitive patterns and psychological frameworks.

Treatment goals are always client-centered and may include:

  • Reducing emotional distress

  • Improving interpersonal relationships

  • Enhancing self-awareness and coping skills

  • Addressing trauma and past experiences

Who Should You Consult?

If you’re unsure which professional to choose, consider the following:

  • For emotional support, stress management, or personal development, a psychotherapist may be ideal.

  • For formal assessment, a clear diagnosis, or treatment of complex mental disorders, consult a psychologist.

  • If medication may be necessary, either professional can refer you to a psychiatrist, who is a medical doctor.

The most important factor is finding someone you trust and feel safe with. Therapeutic progress often depends more on the quality of the relationship than the provider’s title.

Wrapping It Up

While psychologists and psychotherapists both play crucial roles in mental health care, their training, scope of practice, and approach to treatment differ significantly. Psychotherapists are ideal for ongoing emotional support, whereas psychologists are trained to offer deeper psychological insights and assessments. Knowing the distinction helps you access the right care at the right time.

Ready to Take the First Step Toward Better Mental Health?

At Wellman Psychology, we believe that mental health care should be accessible, personalized, and compassionate. Our experienced Chicago Psychologist and psychotherapists are here to support you, whether you’re facing a specific challenge or seeking to better understand yourself. We’ll help you explore which therapeutic path is right for you, whether it’s talk therapy, psychological testing, or a collaborative approach. Your healing journey starts with a single step, and we’re honored to walk alongside you.
Book a consultation today and take the first step toward clarity, balance, and emotional well-being.

Feel free to check out our social media links below:

Find out more articles that can help you below:

What Is Psychotherapy vs Therapy

When to See a Psychiatrist vs Therapist

Should I See a Therapist or a Psychiatrist