Therapist or Psychiatrist—Who Should You See First? Here’s How to Decide
Struggling with your mental health can be confusing, and one of the first hurdles is figuring out where to begin. Should you start with a therapist or jump straight to a psychiatrist? If you’ve been asking yourself, "Should I see a therapist or a psychiatrist?", you’re not alone. The path to mental wellness isn’t one-size-fits-all, and understanding the unique roles of these professionals can help you take that all-important first step with confidence.
In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between therapists and psychiatrists, explore when it’s best to see one over the other, and help you decide which route might be right for your situation. Whether you're dealing with stress, anxiety, mood swings, or something more complex, knowing who to turn to first can make all the difference in getting the right support.
What Is a Psychiatrist?
Psychiatrists are medical doctors (MD or DO) who specialize in diagnosing and treating mental health conditions. Their journey includes:
Completing medical school
Undergoing a residency in psychiatry
Receiving training to understand the biological, neurological, and psychological components of mental health
Because of this medical background, psychiatrists can:
Prescribe medications
Order lab tests or imaging to rule out underlying medical issues
Diagnose complex psychiatric conditions
Develop comprehensive treatment plans, including medication management and, in some cases, talk therapy
Psychiatrists are typically consulted for conditions such as:
Major depressive disorder
Bipolar disorder
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
Schizophrenia
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)
Their approach often combines medication with psychotherapy or referrals to therapists for integrated care.
Psychologist vs. Psychiatrist: What’s the Difference?
While psychiatrists are trained as medical doctors, psychologists hold doctoral degrees (PhD or PsyD) in psychology and are experts in:
Psychological testing and assessment
Behavioral interventions
Talk therapy and counseling
Research and clinical diagnostics
However, psychologists cannot prescribe medication (except in a few U.S. states with additional certification). Their work often overlaps with therapists, but they bring added expertise in evaluating cognitive, developmental, and emotional functioning.
Therapy vs. Psychiatry: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Category
Therapists
Psychiatrists
Education
Master’s degree (e.g., LPC, LCSW, LMFT)
Medical Doctor (MD or DO)
Prescribe Medications
❌ No
✅ Yes
Approach
Talk-based techniques
Medication management, possibly therapy
Typical Duration
Varies (short-term to long-term)
Often ongoing, especially for chronic cases
Referral Flow
May refer to a psychiatrist if meds needed
May recommend therapy as a companion
How Do You Know If You Should Start With a Therapist?
Therapists are often the first line of support for people experiencing emotional or situational challenges. You may benefit from therapy if:
You’re feeling overwhelmed by stress, grief, or life transitions
You want to learn healthier coping mechanisms
You're struggling with relationships or self-esteem
You prefer a non-medication approach to mental health
Your symptoms are manageable, but affecting your day-to-day life
Therapy is especially effective when your issues are rooted in behavioral patterns, emotional responses, or thought distortions that can be improved with structured conversations and skills-building.
When Therapy Alone Might Not Be Enough
Despite its many benefits, therapy does have limitations:
No access to medication: If your condition requires it, you’ll need to see a psychiatrist
Slower progress: Healing can take time and regular effort
Not always effective for severe mental illness without additional medical care
Costs can add up without insurance or sliding-scale options
Can be emotionally intense: Processing trauma or long-held beliefs may initially feel uncomfortable
Signs It Might Be Time to See a Psychiatrist
If you're noticing the following signs, it may be helpful to consult a psychiatrist:
Persistent or severe symptoms that interfere with your daily life
Lack of progress after several therapy sessions
Family history of mental health disorders
Experiences of psychosis, such as hallucinations or delusions
Suicidal thoughts or extreme mood swings
Interest in exploring medication as part of your treatment
Primary care providers often refer patients to psychiatrists when they observe signs that require specialized mental health care.
Why a Psychiatrist Might Refer You to a Therapist
Psychiatrists often recommend talk therapy in conjunction with medication, as research shows this combination can be especially effective. You may be referred to a therapist to:
Address emotional processing and behavioral changes
Learn coping strategies to manage stress, anxiety, or trauma
Explore relationship dynamics and lifestyle changes that affect mental health
This team-based approach ensures that both the medical and emotional aspects of your care are covered.
Why a Therapist Might Refer You to a Psychiatrist
Therapists are trained to monitor changes in your symptoms and can spot when a referral to a psychiatrist is necessary. They might suggest a psychiatric consultation if:
You're not improving with talk therapy alone
Symptoms become more severe, persistent, or disruptive
There’s concern about safety or suicidal thoughts
You show signs of a condition like bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, or major depression
This referral is not a failure—it's a sign that your therapist wants to ensure you receive the full spectrum of care available.
Making the Right Choice for Your Mental Health
Choosing between a therapist and a psychiatrist can feel like a big decision, but you don’t need to get it perfect on the first try. The most important thing is taking that first step toward support.
Whether you start with a therapist or a psychiatrist:
Both can guide you to the right treatment path
They often work collaboratively for your best care
You can switch or add providers as your needs evolve
How Wellman Psychology Can Help
At Wellman Psychology, we’re here to support you through every phase of your mental health journey. Our compassionate Chicago psychologists are trained to help you navigate challenges with insight and care. If medication or psychiatric consultation becomes necessary, we can help connect you with trusted psychiatrists in our network.
You're not alone—and you don’t have to figure this out by yourself. Reach out today to start feeling better and living more fully.
Feel free to check out our social media links below:
Find out more articles that can help you below: